← Back to BlogAI Privacy

    The decision was made by a human. But AI helped make it.

    By Deidentified · 6 Nov 2026 · 2 min read

    With new Australian privacy obligations taking effect on 10 December, Computer Says No, a report released yesterday by the The Centre for Public Integrity, raises important questions about government accountability.

    The report argues that automated decision-making can displace human judgment, obscure who is responsible for a decision, and weaken people's ability to have decisions reviewed.

    The timing is significant: From 10 December, Australian Privacy Principles 1.7 to 1.9 require organisations covered by the Privacy Act to disclose in their privacy policies certain uses of computer programs that process personal information to make, or do things substantially and directly related to making, decisions that could reasonably be expected to significantly affect individuals' rights or interests.

    Having a human make the final decision does not necessarily take an AI-assisted process outside these requirements. The OAIC's guidance says a decision can be in scope even where the program's output is subject to human review.

    Consider an officer using AI to gather evidence, assess an application and prepare a recommendation about access to services. The questions go beyond who makes the final decision:

    What personal information was processed?
    How did the AI output influence the decision?
    Could the decision be explained, challenged or reviewed?

    The new Privacy Act provisions address transparency. The Centre for Public Integrity argues government needs to go further, calling for independent oversight, audits of existing systems, a public transparency register and meaningful human oversight.

    Transparency is necessary. But disclosure is not the same as accountability. For organisations deploying AI, the immediate challenge is knowing where these systems are used, keeping unnecessary personal information out of them, and being able to explain how their outputs shape decisions.

    For local government the governance questions are just as relevant, although councils are generally subject to state rather than Commonwealth privacy law.

    The tool is not the governance.

    Centre for Public Integrity report:

    https://lnkd.in/gy6HHNBn

    Originally posted on LinkedIn on 6 November 2026

    Ready to protect your organisation's data?

    Try for free. No credit card required.

    Start Free Trial

    See Deidentified in Action

    🔊 Turn sound on

    More from our blog